Coronado Market Report – September 2026 – The Cays

Coronado

Whitney's market report is updated monthly to show you the most accurate picture of how the Coronado market is operating.

Single Family Homes

Total Inventory

8

Down 11% from July

Total Sales

1

Down 80% from July

Avg. Sales Price

$2,900,000

Down 30% from July

Avg. Price per SqFt

$958

Down 30% from July

Avg. Days on Market

54

Up 42% from July

Condos

Total Inventory

5

Down 17% from July

Total Sales

4

Up 100% from July

Avg. Sales Price

$1,875,000

Down 55% from July

Avg. Price per SqFt

Avg. Days on Market

Median Sales Price Trend

Single Family Homes and Condos

WB - The Cays - MR - 11x17 - September 2026 - Median Sales Price Trend

About the Coronado Market

Coronado’s market is active, but results are never guaranteed. Today’s luxury buyers are discerning, data-driven, and negotiate hard. When you sell, the gap between a fair outcome and a great one usually comes down to who represents you.

If you have any questions about trends we’re seeing or simply want to better understand the market, I’d love to be a resource for you. Please don’t hesitate to connect with me.

FAQs

Coronado is a small, low-inventory island market. Headline San Diego County statistics can hide what is really happening on the island, where scarcity, walkability, and lifestyle demand move prices differently than the broader county.

The balance shifts month to month with inventory and demand. This report’s metrics — inventory, sales, and days on market — show where things stand this month, and Whitney’s commentary explains what it means for your plans.

Track the Median Sales Price Trend chart in this report. Coronado has historically seen strong long-term appreciation driven by its limited supply of homes, though month-to-month movement varies by property type.

Average Days on Market in this report is the best monthly gauge. Well-priced, well-presented homes have historically moved quickly here — some sales close off-market before ever being listed.

Location within Coronado (Village, Shores, Cays), views, lot size, condition, and the depth of off-market buyer demand all play a role. Staging and presentation also matter significantly in this discerning market.

It depends on your goals, timeline, and property type. Use this month’s data as a starting point, then connect with Whitney for a personalized read on your specific home and neighborhood.

The fastest way to find out is a personalized valuation. Contact Whitney for a data-driven estimate based on recent comparable sales and current off-market activity.

Exclusive Listings of Whitney Benzian